'Unconditional surrender' is a
surrender without conditions, except for those provided by
international law. Normally a belligerent will only agree to surrender unconditionally if completely incapable of continuing hostilities. Announcing that only unconditional surrender is acceptable puts psychological pressure on a weaker adversary. It has also been criticized for forcing an opponent into a position where he has nothing to gain by negotiation or
diplomacy, and might as well fight to the bitter end. The most notable uses of the term have been by the
United States in the
American Civil War and
World War II.
In the era post World War II, the comparable example of unconditional surrender is that of the
Pakistani army in
East Pakistan at the hands of the
Indian army and the
Mukti Bahini during the
Indo-Pakistani War of 1971 or the latter half of
Bangladesh Liberation War. Here 93,000 Pakistani soldiers surrendered unconditionally to the Indian Allied Forces (
Mitro Bahini) commander Lt Gen.
Jagjit Singh Aurora.
United States usage
The most famous early use of the phrase occurred during the 1862
Battle of Fort Donelson in the
American Civil War.
Brigadier General Ulysses S. Grant of the
Union Army received a request for terms from the fort's commanding officer,
Confederate Brigadier General
Simon Bolivar Buckner. Grant's reply was that "no terms except unconditional and immediate surrender can be accepted. I propose to move immediately upon your works." When news of Grant's victory—one of the Union's first in the Civil War—was received in
Washington, D.C., newspapers remarked (and
President Abraham Lincoln endorsed) that Ulysses Simpson Grant's first two initials, "U.S.," stood for "Unconditional Surrender," which would later become his nickname.
However, subsequent surrenders to Grant were not unconditional. When
Robert E. Lee surrendered his
Army of Northern Virginia at
Appomattox Court House in 1865, Grant agreed to allow the men under Lee's command to go home under parole and to keep sidearms and private horses. Generous terms were also offered to
John C. Pemberton at
Vicksburg and (by Grant's subordinate,
William T. Sherman) to
Joseph E. Johnston in
North Carolina.
The use of the term was revived during
World War II at the
Casablanca conference when American President
Franklin D. Roosevelt offered it to the other
Allies and the press as the objective of the war against the Axis Powers of
Germany,
Italy, and
Japan. The term was also used at the end of
World War II when
Japan surrendered to the
United States.
"Unconditional Surrender" is also the name of a
statue dedicated to the city of
San Diego, California, a sculpture based on the famous "
V-J Day Kiss" photograph taken by
Alfred Eisenstaedt of a sailor kissing a nurse in Times Square, New York City, in 1945.
A similar statue was erected in Sarasota, Florida in 2006 as part of their street art display. Many area residents and visitors were so impressed with the forty-eight foot tall statute that it became "the place" to have your picture taken. The statute was dismantled in May of 2006 but is said to be replaced by a permanent statute in the same area in the near future. No erection date has been announced.
It was also seen at the
Battle of the Alamo, when
Santa Anna asked
Jim Bowie and
William B. Travis for unconditional surrender. Even though Bowie wished surrender unconditionally, Travis refused and retaliated by firing a cannon at Santa Anna's army
See also
★
Military rule
★
Conditional surrender
★
Suing for peace
External links
★
German Surrender Documents of WWII (US Historical Documents)