'Refractive eye surgery' is any
eye surgery used to improve the refractive state of the
eye and decrease dependency on
glasses or
contact lenses. This can include various methods of surgical remodelling of the cornea or cataract surgery. The most common methods today use
excimer lasers to reshape curvature of the
cornea. Successful refractive eye surgery can help to reduce common vision disorders such as
myopia,
hyperopia and
astigmatism.
According to surveys of members of the American Society of Cataract and Refractive Surgery, approximately 948,266 refractive surgery procedures were performed in the United States during 2004 and 928,737 in 2005.
[1]
History
The first experimental studies about refractive surgery were developed by
Lendeer Jans Lans, an ophtalmology teacher in
Holland,
1896 where he published a theoric work proposing penetrant corneal cuts to correct
astigmatism. In
1930 the
japanese ophtalmologyst
Sato made the fist practical attempt to perform such surgery in military pilots. He practiced radial cuts in the cornea to correct effects up to 6 dyoptries, but this procedure was soon rejected by the medical community because the high rate of corneal degeneration.
In
1963, in the Barraquer ophtalmologic clinic (
Bogotá,
Colombia)
Ignacio Barraquer developed the first proficient technique to refractive surgery, called
keratomileusis (from the greek Kerato: cornea and Mileusis: to sculpt) meaning corneal reshaping. Keratomileusis allowed to correct not only myopia but also hyperopia. The early surgeries were made removing a corneal layer, freezing it so it could be manually sculpted in the required shape and finally reimplant the layer (Keratomileusis with freezing). In 1986 Dr Swinger improved the surgery (keratomileusis without freezing) but it was still a slightly imprecise technique.
In 1958
Arthur Schawlow and Townes, from
Bell laboratories published their theory of stimuled emission of shorter length waves, included light, which gave place to the development of
Laser. In 1975 experiments with laser using a mix of
argon and
fluor ended with the invention of the Excimer. This Laser was used with industrial purposes. In 1980, R. Srinivasan, a scientist of
IBM who was using the Excimer to make microscopic circuits in
microchips for informatic quipments, discovered that the Excimer could be used also to cut organic tissues with high accuracy without significant thermal damage. In 1983 Stephen Trokel, scientist of
Columbia University in collaboration with Srinivasan performed the Photorefractive Keratectomy (PRK) or keratomileusis in situ (without separation of corneal layer) wich was more technically exact, but the patients reported it to be very umcomfortable. Also a delay in the healing was observed. The first PRK was performed in
Germany.
In 1991 the
Creta University and the Vardinoyannion Eye developed the
Lasik that worked with the same principles, but removing first a lens shaped piece of the outer layer of the cornea, sculpting the inner layer and relocating the piece to cover, which allows a better healing, without discomfort.
Techniques
Flap procedures
Consists in cutting a flap in the cornea in order to access the tissue underneath.
★
Automated lamellar keratoplasty (ALK): The surgeon uses an instrument called a
microkeratome to cut a thin flap of the corneal tissue. The flap is lifted like a hinged door, targeted tissue is removed from the corneal stroma, again with the microkeratome, and then the flap is replaced.
★
Laser Assisted In-Situ Keratomileusis (LASIK) is the most commonly performed refractive surgery procedure as of 2007. Surface treatment ablation has gained a renewed interest in recent years as evidence of good outcomes have been shown. LASIK is performed for a wide range of nearsightedness. The surgeon uses a
microkeratome to cut a flap of the corneal tissue (usually with about 160 micron in thickness). The flap is lifted like a hinged door, but in contrast to ALK, the targeted tissue is removed from the corneal stroma with an excimer laser. The flap is subsequently replaced. Some variations do not use a microkeratome but create the flap with a laser.
★
Laser Assisted Sub-Epithelium Keratomileusis (LASEK) is a procedure that changes the shape of the cornea using an
excimer laser to ablate the tissue from the corneal stroma, under the corneal epithelium, which is kept almost intact to act as a natural
bandage.
★
EPI-LASIK is a new technique similar to LASEK, that uses an epi-keratome (rather than a trephine blade and alcohol) to remove the top layer of the cornea.
Photoablation procedures
★
Photorefractive keratectomy (PRK) is an outpatient procedure generally performed with local
anesthetic eye drops (as LASIK) . It is a type of refractive surgery which reshapes the cornea by destroying microscopic amounts of tissue from corneal stroma, using the computer-controlled beam of light (an
excimer laser). The difference from LASIK is that all the epithelium is removed (and a bandage contact lens must be used). Recovery time is much longer with PRK than with LASIK, though the final outcome (after 3 months) is about the same (very good). More recently, customized ablation have been performed either with LASIK or PRK.
Corneal incision procedures
★
Radial keratotomy (RK) uses spoke-shaped incisions (usually made with a diamond knife) to alter the shape of the cornea and reduce myopia or astigmatism; this technique has now been largely replaced by the other methods (that use excimer laser).
★ Arcuate keratotomy (AK) is similar to radial keratotomy, but the incisions on the cornea are done at the periphery of the cornea. Arcuate keratotomy is used to correct astigmatism. Although most incisional procedures are replaced nowadays by Lasik, AK is still used in some special cases (correction of residual astigmatism after a keratoplasty procedure or during cataract surgery).
Other procedures
★
Thermal keratoplasty is used to correct
hyperopia by putting a ring of 8 or 16 small burns surrounding the pupil, and steepen the cornea with a ring of collagen constriction. It can also be used to treat selected types of astigmatism.
★
Laser thermal keratoplasty (LTK) is a no-touch thermal keratoplasty performed with a
Holmium laser, while
conductive keratoplasty (CK) is thermal keratoplasty performed with a high-frequency electric probe. Thermal keratoplasty can also be used to improve presbyopia or reading vision after age 40.
★ Intra-Stromal corneal rings (Intacs) are approved by FDA for treatment of low degrees of myopia.
★ Lens implantation inside the eye can also be used to change refractive errors.
Expectations
The
Council for Refractive Surgery Quality Assurance, an independent, nonprofit, patient/consumer health organization that provides information about refractive surgery and certifies LASIK surgeons, considers surgeons with results of 90% of patients achieving 20/40 or better and 50% achieving 20/20 or better with limited complication rates as meeting national norms.
[2]
Many people with myopia are able to read comfortably without eyeglasses. Myopes considering refractive surgery are advised that this may be an advantage after the age of 40 when the eyes become
presbyopic and lose their ability to
accommodate or change focus.
Risks
While refractive surgery is becoming more affordable and safe, it may not be recommended for everybody. Patients that have medical conditions such as
glaucoma or
diabetes, uncontrolled vascular disease, autoimmune disease, pregnant women or people with certain
eye diseases involving the
cornea or
retina, are not good candidates for refractive surgery.
Keratoconus, a progressive thinning of the cornea, is a common corneal disorder. It is believed that additional thinning of the cornea via refractive surgery may contribute to advancement of the disease
[3]
, that may lead to the need for a
corneal transplant. Therefore, keratoconus is a contraindication to refractive surgery. Corneal topography,
paquimetry and, more recently, Pentacam exams are used to screen for abnormal corneas. Furthermore, some people's eye shape may not permit effective refractive surgery without removing excessive amounts of corneal tissue. Those considering laser eye surgery should have a full
eye examination.
References
1. http://www.aao.org/news/academy_express/20060405.cfm
2. http://www.usaeyes.org/faq/subjects/odds.htm
3. Research of corneal ectasia following laser in-situ keratomileusis in rabbits. Huang X, He X, Tan X.
See also
★
Orthokeratology - contact lenses worn only at night to reshape the eye.
External links
★
DJO | Digital Journal of Ophthalmology
★
Refractive eye surgery video