(Redirected from Qing)
The 'Qing Dynasty' (;
Manchu:
daicing gurun;
Mongolian: Манж Чин Улс), also known as the 'Manchu Dynasty' or the 'Chinese Empire' by contemporaries, was the ruling
dynasty of
China from 1644 to 1911. The dynasty was founded by the
Manchu clan
Aisin Gioro in what is today
northeast China (
Manchuria). Starting in 1644 it expanded into
China proper and its surrounding territories, establishing the 'Empire of the Great Qing' (). The Qing Dynasty was the last
Imperial dynasty of China. Declared as the 'Later Jin Dynasty' in 1616, it changed its name to "Qing", meaning "clear" or "pellucid", in 1636 and captured
Beijing in 1644. By 1646 it had come into power over most of present-day China, although complete pacification of China would not be accomplished until 1683.
During its reign, the Qing Dynasty was highly integrated with
Chinese culture. However, its military power weakened during the 1800s, and faced with international pressure, massive
rebellions and defeats in
wars, the Qing Dynasty declined after the mid-19th century. The Qing Dynasty was overthrown following the
Xinhai Revolution, when
Empress Dowager Longyu abdicated on behalf of the last emperor,
Puyi, on
February 12,
1912.
Formation of the Manchu State

Flag of Qing Dynasty, 1862–1890
The Dynasty was founded not by the
Han Chinese who form the majority of the Chinese population, but the
Manchus, who are today an ethnic minority within
China. The
Manchus are decended from
Jurchens (
Zh: 女真), a
Tungusic people who lived around the region now comprising the
Russian province of
Primorsky Krai and the
Chinese province of
Heilongjiang. What was to become the
Manchu state was founded by
Nurhachi, the chieftain of a minor
Jurchen tribe in ''Jianzhou'' (
Zh: 建州), in the early seventeenth century. Originally a vassal of
Ming Dynasty,
Nurhaci in 1582 embarked on an inter-tribal feud that escalated into a campaign to unify the ''Jianzhou''
Jurchen tribes. By 1616 he had sufficiently consolidated ''Jianzhou'' region to proclaim himself
Khan of 'Great Jin' in reference to the previous
Jurchen dynasty. Historians refer to this pre-Qing entity as 'Later Jin' to distinguish it from the first
Jin Dynasty. Two years later
Nurhachi openly renounced the sovereignty of
Ming's overlordship in order to complete the unification of those
Jurchen tribes still allied to
Ming Dynasty. After a series of successful battles he relocated his capital from ''Hetu Ala'' to successively bigger captured
Ming cities in the province of
Liaodong (
Zh: 辽东), first
Liaoyang (
Zh: 辽阳;
Ma: ''dergi hecen'') in 1621 and again in 1625 to
Shenyang (
Zh: 沈阳; later renamed Shengjing;
Zh: 盛京;
Ma: ''Mukden'').
Relocating his court from ''Jianzhou'' to
Liaodong provided
Nurhaci a bigger power base in terms of human and material resources; geographically it also brought him in close contact with the
Mongol domains on the plains of Mongolia. Although by this time the once united
Mongol nation under
Genghis Khan had long fragmented into individual and at times hostile tribes, these disunited tribes still presented a serious security threat to
Ming's borders.
Nurhaci's policy towards the
Mongols was to seek their friendship and cooperation, thus securing the
Jurchen's western front from a potential enemy. Furthermore, the
Mongols proved a useful ally in the war lending the
Jurchens their traditional expertise as cavalry archers. To cement this new alliance
Nurhaci initiated a policy of inter-marriages between
Jurchen and those
Mongolian nobility compliant to
Jurchen leadership, while those who resisted were met with military action. This is a typical example of
Nurhachi's many initiatives that eventually became official Qing government policy, as such
Nurhachi is widely credited by historians as well as his descendents - successive Qing emperors as the founder of the Dynasty. Some of
Nurhaci's other important contributions include ordering the creation of a written
Manchu language based on
Mongolian script, and the creation of the civil and military administrative system that eventually evolved into the
Manchu Banners the defining element of
Manchu identity, thus laying foundation for transforming the loosely knitted
Jurchen tribes into a nation.

Qing Dynasty era brush container
Nurhaci's unbroken series of military successes came to an end in January 1626 when he was dealt his first major military defeat by general
Yuan Chonghuan while laying siege to the
Ming city of Ningyuan. (Please read
Battle of Ningyuan). He died a few months later
[1] and was succeeded by his eighth son
Hung Taiji who emerged after a short political struggle amongst other potential contenders as the new
Khan. Although an experienced general and the commander of two
Banners at the time of his succession,
Hung Taiji's reign did not start well on the military front. The
Jurchens suffered yet another defeat in 1627 at the hands of
Yuan Chonghuan. As was in the previous year this defeat was the result of the superior firepower of
Ming forces' newly acquired Portuguese sourced cannons. To redress the technological and numerical disparity
Hung Taiji in 1634 created his own artillery corps (
Zh: 重军,
Ma: ''ujen chooha'') from amongst his existing Han troops who casted their own cannons from European design with the help of captured Chinese artisans. In 1635 the
Manchu's
Mongolian allies were fully incorporated into a separate Banner hierarchy under direct
Manchu command. Hong Taiji then defeated in 1637 the army of King Injo of
Korea with the aftermath being that (i) Korea becomes a tributary state of the Manchus and (ii) Korea will serve in the upcoming war against Ming China. Together with the Korean troops and troops formed from the various tribes conquered in Manchuria, the Manchus led by
Hung Taiji were able to resoundingly defeat
Ming forces in a series of battles from 1640 to 1642 for the territories of ''Songshan'' (
Zh: 松山)) and ''Jingzhou'' (
Zh: 锦州)). This final victory resulted in the surrender of many of
Ming Dynasty's most battle hardened troops and the complete permanent withdrawal of remaining
Ming forces from lands north of the Great Wall.
On the civil front,
Hung Taiji, on the advice of surrendered
Ming officials, set up a rudimentary bureaucratic system based on the
Ming model of government.
Hung Taiji's bureaucracy was staffed with an unprecedented number of Han Chinese, many of them newly surrendered
Ming officials. However
Jurchen continued dominance in government was ensured by an ethnic quota for top bureaucratic appointments.
Hung Taiji's reign also saw a fundamental change of policy towards his Han Chinese subjects. Whereas under
Nurhaci all captured Han Chinese were seen as a potential
fifth column for the
Ming Dynasty and treated as chattel - including those who eventually held important government posts,
Hung Taiji in contrast incorporated them into the
Jurchen "nation" as full if not first class citizens who too were obligated to provide military service. This change of policy not only increased
Hung Taiji's powerbase and reduced his military dependence on those
Banners not under his personal control, it also greatly encouraged other Han Chinese subjects of
Ming Dynasty to surrender and accept
Jurchen rule when they were defeated militarily. Through these and other measures
Hung Taiji was able to centralize power unto the office of the
Khan which in the long run prevented the
Jurchen federation from fragmenting after his death.
One of the most defining events of
Hung Taiji's reign was the official adoption of the name "
Manchu" (
Zh: 满族) for all
Jurchen people in November 1635. And when the imperial seal of the
Yuan emperors was presented to
Hung Taiji by the son of Ligden Khan, the last grand-Khan of the
Mongols,
Hung Taiji in 1636 renamed the state from "Later Jin" to "Great Qing" and elevated his position from
Khan to
Emperor, suggesting imperial ambitions beyond unifying
Manchu territories. Some sources suggested that the name "Qing" was chosen in reaction to that of the
Ming Dynasty (明) which consists of the
Chinese characters for sun (日) and moon (月), which are associated with the fire element. The character Qing (清) is composed of the water (水) radical and the character for blue-green (青), which are both associated with the water element. Other suggested that the name change went a long way to rehabilitate the
Manchu state in the eyes of the
Ming era Han Chinese who being heavily infleunced by a Neo-Confucian education system had regarded the former
Jurchen Jin dynasty as foreign invaders.
Claiming the Mandate of Heaven
Hung Taiji died suddenly in September 1643 without a designated heir. Because
Jurchen had traditionally "elected" their leader through a council of nobles, the Qing state did not have in place a clear succession system until the reign of
Emperor Kangxi. The leading contenders for power at this time were
Hung Taiji’s eldest son
Hooge and
Hung Taiji’s
agnate half brother
Dorgon. In the ensuing political impasse between two bitter political rivals a compromise candidate in the person of
Hung Taiji’s five year old son
Fulin was installed as
Emperor Shunzhi with
Dorgon as regent and ''
de facto'' leader of the
Manchu nation. Fortunately the
Manchus' nemesis the
Ming Dynasty was fighting for its own survival against a long drawn peasant rebellion and was unable to capitalise on the Qing court’s political uncertainty over the succession dispute and installation of a minor as Emperor.
Ming Dynasty's internal crisis came to a head in 1644, when the capital at modern day
Beijing was sacked by a coalition of rebel forces led by
Li Zicheng, a minor
Ming official turned leader of a peasant revolt. The last
Ming Emperor
Chongzhen committed suicide when the city fell, marking the official end of the dynasty.
After easily taking
Beijing in April, 1644,
Li Zicheng led a coalition of rebel forces numbering 200,000
[2] to confront
Wu Sangui, the general commanding
Ming's
garrison at
Shanhai Guan (
Zh:山海關).
Shanhai Guan is a pivotal
pass of the
Great Wall of China located fifty miles northeast of
Beijing and for years its
defenses were what kept the
Manchus from directly raiding the
Ming capital.
Wu caught between a rebel army twice his size and a foreign enemy he had fought for years, decided to cast his lot with the
Manchus which he was familiar with and made an alliance with
Dorgon to fight the rebels. Some sources suggested that
Wu Sangui's actions were influenced by news of mistreatment of his family and his concubine
Chen Yuanyuan at the hands of the rebels when the
Ming capital fell. Regardless of the actual reason(s) for his decision
[3], this awkward and some would say cynical alliance between
Wu Sangui and his former sworn enemy was ironically made in the name of avenging the death of
Ming Emperor
Chongzhen. Together, the two former enemies met and defeated
Li Zicheng's rebel forces in battle on
May 27,
1644. After routing
Li's forces the
Manchu captured
Beijing on June 6 where
Emperor Shunzhi was installed as the
"Son of Heaven" on October 30. The
Manchus who had positioned themselves as political heir to the
Ming Emperor by defeating
Li Zicheng, completed the symbolic act of transition by holding a former funeral for
Emperor Chongzhen. However the process of conquest took another seventeen years of battling
Ming loyalists,
pretenders and rebels. The last
Ming pretender,
Prince Gui, sought refuge with the King of
Burma a vassal of the
Ming Dynasty but was turned over to a Qing expeditionary army commanded by
Wu Sangui who had him brought back to
Yunnan province and
executed in early 1662.
The first seven years of
Shunzhi’s reign was dominated by the regent prince
Dorgon who because of his own political insecurity within the
Manchu power structure followed
Hung Taiji’s example of centralizing power unto himself in the name of the
Emperor at the expense of other contenting
Manchu princes many whom eventually were demoted or imprisoned under one pretext or another. Although the period of his regency was relatively short,
Dorgon cast a long shadow over the Qing Dynasty. Firstly the
Manchus were able to enter "China Proper" only because of
Dorgon’s timely decision to act on
Wu Sangui’s appeal for military assistance. After capturing
Beijing instead of sacking the city as the rebels had done before them,
Dorgon insisted over other
Manchu princes on making it Qing’s capital and largely reappointed
Ming officials back to their posts. Setting the Qing capital in
Beijing may seem a straight forward move with hindsight, but it was then an act of innovation because historically no major Chinese dynasty had ever "inherited" its immediate predecessor’s capital. Keeping the
Ming capital and bureaucracy intact helped quickly stabilize the country and greatly sped up
Manchu's process of conquest. However not all of
Dorgon’s policies were equally popular nor easily implemented. One of his most controversial decisions was his 1646 imperial edict ordering all Han Chinese men to follow
Manchu custom of dressing including shaving the front of their heads and combing the remaining hair into a queue. To the
Manchus this policy might both be a symbolic act of submission and in practical terms an aid in identification of friend from foe, however for the Han Chinese it totally went against their traditional Confucian values
[4]. Unsurprisingly it was deeply unpopular and together with other policies unfavourable towards the Han Chinese might account for the increasingly steep resistance met by Qing forces after 1646.
Dorgon died suddenly while on a hunting expedition in 1651
[5] marking the official start of
Emperor Shunzhi’s personal rule. However because the
Emperor was only twelve years old at that time, most decisions were made on his behalf by his mother, the
Empress Dowager Xiao-Zhuang who turned out to be a skilled political operator. Although
Dorgon’s “support” was paramount to
Shunzhi’s ascend and rule in the early years of the
Emperor’s reign,
Dorgon had through the years centralised so much power unto his office as imperial regent to become a direct threat to the throne, so much so that upon his death
Dorgon was extraordinarily bestowed the posthumous title of
Emperor Yi (
Zh: 義皇帝), the only instance in Qing history of a
Manchu "
prince of the blood" (
Zh: 亲王) was so honoured. However two months into
Shunzhi’s personal rule
Dorgon was not only striped of his titles, but his corpse was disinterred and mutilated
[6] to atone for multiple "crimes" - one of which was persecuting to death
Shunzhi’s
agnate eldest brother
Hooge. More importantly
Dorgon’s symbolic fall from grace also signalled a political
purge of his family and associates in court thus reverting power back to the person of the
Emperor. However from a promising start,
Shunzhi’s reign was cut short by his early death in 1661 at the age of twenty-four from
smallpox[7]. He was succeeded by his third son
Xuan-Ye who became
Emperor Kangxi.
Kangxi and consolidation
At sixty one years,
Kangxi had the longest reign of any
Emperor of China. But more importantly, apart from its length,
Kangxi’s reign is also celebrated as the beginning of an era called “Kang-Qian Golden Age” (
Zh: 康乾盛世) during which Qing Dynasty reached the zenith of its social, economic and military power.
Kangxi’s long reign started when he was eight years old upon the untimely demise of his father. In order to prevent a repeat of
Dorgon's dictatorial monopolizing of imperial powers during the period of regency,
Emperor Shunzhi on his deathbed hastily appointed four senior cabinet ministers to govern on behalf of his young son. The four ministers --
Sonin,
Ebilun,
Suksaha, and
Oboi were chosen for their long service to the crown, but also to counteract each others' influences. Most importantly, the four were not closely related to the imperial family and laid no claim to the throne. However as time passed, through chance and machination,
Oboi the most junior of the four ministers, was able to achieve political dominance to such an extend as to become a potential threat to the crown. Even though
Oboi's loyalty was never an issue, his personal arrogance and political conservatism led him to come into ever escalating conflict with the young
Emperor. In 1669
Kangxi through trickery disarmed and imprisoned
Oboi, a not insignificant victory for the a fifteen year old
Emperor as
Oboi was not only a wily old politician but also an experience military commander.
The Manchus found controlling the "
Mandate of Heaven" a daunting task. The vastness of China's territory meant that there were only enough banner troops to garrison key cities forming the backbone of a defence network that relied heavily on surrendered Ming soldiers. In addition, three surrendered Ming generals were singled out for their contributions to the establishment of the Qing dynasty, ennobled as feudal princes (藩王), and given governorships over vast territories in Southern China. The chief of these was
Wu Sangui (吳三桂), who was given the provinces of Yunnan and
Guizhou, while generals
Shang Kexi (尚可喜) and
Geng Zhongming (耿仲明) were given the
Guangdong and
Fujian provinces, respectively.

Pilgrim flask,
porcelain with underglaze blue and iron-red decoration. Qing dynasty, Qianlong period in the eighteenth century.
As the years went by, the three feudal lords and their territories inevitably became increasingly autonomous. Finally, in 1673, Shang Kexi petitioned Kangxi Emperor, stating his desire to retire to his hometown in Liaodong (遼東) province and nominating his son as his successor. The young emperor granted his retirement, but denied the heredity of his fief. In reaction, the two other generals decided to petition for their own retirements to test Kangxi's resolve, thinking that he would not risk offending them. The move backfired as the young emperor called their bluff by accepting their requests and ordering all three fiefdoms to be reverted back to the crown.
Faced with the stripping of their powers, Wu Sangui felt he had no choice but to rise up in revolt. He was joined by Geng Zhongming and by Shang Kexi's son Shang Zhixin (尚之信). The ensuing rebellion lasted for eight years. At the peak of the rebels' fortunes, they managed to extend their control as far north as the Yangtze River (長江). Ultimately, though, the Qing government was able to put down the rebellion and exert control over all of southern China. The rebellion would be known in Chinese history as the
Revolt of the Three Feudatories.
To consolidate the empire,
Kangxi Emperor personally led China on a series of military campaigns against
Tibet, the
Dzungars, and later
Russia. He arranged the marriage of his daughter to the Mongol Khan
Gordhun to avoid a military conflict. Gordhun's military campaign against the Qing failed, further strengthening the Empire.
Taiwan was also conquered by Qing Empire forces in 1683 from
Zheng Jing's son,
Zheng Keshuang. Zheng Keshuang's grandfather
Koxinga had conquered Taiwan from the
Dutch colonists to use it as a base against the Qing Dynasty. By the end of the seventeenth century, China was at the height of its most power since the early
Ming Dynasty.
Kangxi Emperor also handled many
Jesuit Missionaries that came to China hoping for mass conversions. Although they failed in their attempt, Kangxi peacefully kept the missionaries in
Beijing.
The Yongzheng and Qianlong emperors
The reigns of the
Yongzheng Emperor (r. 1723–1735) and his son the
Qianlong Emperor (r. 1735–1796) marked the height of Qing's power. During this period, the Qing Dynasty ruled over 13 million square kilometres of territory.
After the Kangxi Emperor's death in the winter of 1722, his fourth son Prince Yong (雍親王) succeeded him as the
Yongzheng Emperor. Yongzheng remained a controversial character because of rumours about him usurping the throne, and in the late Kangxi years, he was involved in great political struggles with his brothers. Yongzheng was a hardworking administrator who ruled with an iron hand. His first big step towards a stronger regime came when he brought the
State Examination System back to its original standards. In 1724, he cracked down on illegal exchange rates of coins, which was being manipulated by officials to fit their financial needs. Those who were found in violation of new laws on finances were removed from office, or in extreme cases, executed.
Yongzheng showed a great amount of trust in
Han officials, and appointed many of his proteges to prestigious positions.
Nian Gengyao was appointed to lead a military campaign in place of his brother
Yinti in
Qinghai. Nian's arrogant actions, however, led to his downfall in 1726. Yongzheng's reign saw consolidation of imperial power at its height in Chinese history. More territory was incorporated in the Northwest. A toughened stance was directed towards corrupt officials, and Yongzheng led the creation of a
Grand Council, which grew to become the de facto Cabinet for the rest of the dynasty.
The Yongzheng Emperor died in 1735. This was followed by the succession of his son Prince Bao (寶親王) as the
Qianlong Emperor. Qianlong was known as an able general. Succeeding the throne at the age of 24, Qianlong personally led the military in campaigns near
Xinjiang and
Mongolia. Revolts and uprisings in
Sichuan and parts of southern China were successfully put down.
Around forty years into Qianlong's reign, the Qing government saw a return of rampant corruption. The official
Heshen was arguably one of the most corrupt in the entire Qing Dynasty. He was eventually forced into committing suicide by Qianlong's son, the
Jiaqing Emperor (r. 1796–1820).
Rebellion, unrest and external pressure
A common view of nineteenth century China is that it was an era in which Qing control weakened and prosperity diminished. Indeed, China suffered massive social strife, economic stagnation, and explosive population growth which placed an increasing strain on the food supply. Historians offer various explanations for these events, but the basic idea is that Qing power was, over the course of the century, faced with internal problems and natural disasters which were simply too much for the antiquated Chinese government, bureaucracy, and economy to deal with.

Flag of Qing Dynasty, 1890–1912
The
Taiping Rebellion in the mid-nineteenth century was the first major instance of anti-Manchu sentiment threatening the stability of the Qing dynasty, a phenomenon that would only increase in the following years. However, the horrific number of casualties of this rebellion—as many as 30 million people—and the complete devastation of a huge area in the south of the country have to a large extent been overshadowed by another significant conflict. Although not nearly as bloody, the outside world and its ideas and technologies had a tremendous and ultimately revolutionary impact on an increasingly weak and uncertain Qing state. The Qing government would go on to face more revolts, this time by
Muslims who would fight the
Panthay Rebellion (1856-1873) and the
Dungan revolt (1862-1877).
One of the major issues affecting nineteenth-century China was the question of how to deal with other countries. Prior to the nineteenth-century, the
Chinese empire was the hegemonic power in Asia. Under its imperial theory, the Chinese emperor had the rights to rule "
all under heaven". Depending on the period and dynasty, it either ruled territories directly or neighbors fell under its hierarchical tributary system. Historians often refer to the underlying concept of Chinese empire as "an empire with no boundary." However, the eighteenth century saw the European empires gradually expand across the world, as European states developed stronger economies built on
maritime trade. European colonies had been established in nearby
India and on the islands that are now part of
Indonesia, whilst the
Russian Empire had annexed the areas north of China. In 1793,
Great Britain attempted to forge an alliance with China, sending the
Macartney Embassy to
Hong Kong with gifts for the Emperor, including examples of the latest European technologies and art. When the British delegation received a letter from
Peking explaining that China was unimpressed with European achievements, and that
George III was welcome to pay homage to the Chinese court, the deeply offended British government aborted all further attempts to reconcile relations with the Qing regime.
When the Napoleonic Wars ended in 1815, world trade rapidly increased, and as China's vast population offered limitless markets for European goods, trade between Chinese and European merchants expanded during the early years of the nineteenth century. This increased trade, though, led to increasing hostility between European governments and the Qing regime.
In 1793, the Qianlong Emperor stated to the British Ambassador
Lord Macartney that China had no use for European manufactured products.
[8] Consequently, leading Chinese merchants only accepted bar
silver as payment for their goods. The huge demand in Europe for Chinese goods such as
silk,
tea, and
ceramics could only be met if European companies funnelled their limited supplies of silver into China. By the late 1830s, the governments of
Great Britain and
France were deeply concerned about their stockpiles of precious metals and sought alternate trading schemes with China - the foremost of which was addicting China with opium. When the Qing regime tried to ban the opium trade in 1838, Great Britain declared war on China.
The
First Opium War revealed the outdated state of the Chinese military. The Qing navy, composed entirely of wooden sailing
junks, was severely outclassed by the modern tactics and firepower of the
Royal Navy at its apex. British soldiers, using modern
rifles and
artillery, easily outmanoeuvred and outgunned Qing forces in ground battles. The Qing surrender in 1842 marked a decisive, humiliating blow to China. The
Treaty of Nanking, which demanded
reparation payments, allowed unrestricted European access to Chinese ports, and ceded the
island of Hong Kong to Great Britain. It revealed many inadequacies in the Qing government and provoked widespread rebellions against the already hugely unpopular regime.
The Western powers, largely unsatisfied with the Treaty of Nanking, only gave grudging support to the Qing government during the
Taiping and
Nien Rebellions. China's income fell sharply during the wars as vast areas of farmland were destroyed, millions of lives lost, and countless armies raised and equipped to fight the rebels. In 1854, Great Britain tried to re-negotiate the Treaty of Nanking, inserting clauses allowing British commercial access to Chinese rivers and the creation of a permanent British embassy at
Peking. This last clause outraged the Qing regime, who refused to sign, provoking another war with Britain. The
Second Opium War ended in another crushing Chinese defeat, whilst the
Treaty of Tianjin contained clauses deeply insulting to the Chinese, such as a demand that all official Chinese documents be written in
English and a proviso granting British warships unlimited access to all navigable Chinese rivers.
The rule of Empress Dowager Cixi
.PNG)
Empress Dowager Cixi
In the late nineteenth century, a new leader emerged. The
Empress Dowager Cixi,
concubine to the
Emperor Xianfeng (r. 1850–1861), the mother of child emperor
Tongzhi, and Aunt of
Guangxu successfully controlled the Qing government and was the
de facto leader of China for 47 years. She staged a
coup d'état to oust the regency led by
Sushun appointed by the late Emperor. She was known for "ruling from behind the curtain" (垂簾聽政).
By the 1860s, the Qing dynasty had put down the rebellions with the help of
militia organized by the gentry. The Qing government then proceeded to deal with problem of modernization, which it attempted with the
Self-Strengthening Movement. Several modernized armies were formed including the much renowned
Beiyang Army; however the fleets of "Beiyang" were annihilated in the
Sino-Japanese War (1894-1895), which produced calls for greater and more extensive reform. After the start of the twentieth century, the Qing Dynasty was in a dilemma. It could proceed with reform and thereby alienate the conservative gentry or it could stall reform and thereby alienate the revolutionaries. The Qing Dynasty tried to follow a middle path, but proceeded to alienate everyone.
Ten years into the reign of
Guangxu (r. 1875–1908), western pressure on China was so great that she forcefully gave up all sorts of power. In 1898 Guangxu attempted the
Hundred Days' Reform (百日維新/戊戌變法), in which new laws were put in place and some old rules were abolished. Newer, more progressive-minded thinkers like
Kang Youwei were trusted and recognized conservative-minded people like
Li Hongzhang were removed from high positions. But the ideals were stifled by Cixi and Guangxu was jailed in his own palace. Cixi concentrated on centralizing her own power base. At the occasion of her sixtieth Birthday, she spent over 30 million
taels of silver for the decorations & events, funds that were originally to improve the weaponry of the
Beiyang Navy.
In 1901, following the murder of the German Ambassador, the
Eight-Nation Alliance (八國聯軍) entered China as a united military force for the second time. Cixi reacted by declaring war on all eight nations, only to lose
Beijing under their control within a short period of time. Along with the Guangxu Emperor, she fled to
Xi'an. As a military compensation, the Alliance listed scores of demands on the Qing Government, including an initial hit list which had Cixi as No. 1.
Li Hongzhang was sent to negotiate and the Alliance backed down from several of the demands.
Qing government and society

Qing China in 1892
Politics
The Qing were very clever in stabilizing the government. The most important administrative body of the Qing dynasty was the Trung Council which was a body composed of the emperor and high officials. The Qing dynasty was characterized by a system of dual appointments by which each position in the central government had a Manchu and a Han assigned to it. During the
Qianlong Emperor's reign, for example, members of his family were distinguished by garments with a large circular emblem on the back, whereas a Han could only hope to wear clothing with a square emblem; this meant effectively that any guard in the court could immediately distinguish family members from the back view alone.
With respect to Mongolia, Tibet, and Eastern Turkestan, like other dynasties before it the Qing maintained imperial control, with the emperor acting as Mongol khan, patron of Tibetan Buddhism and protector of Muslims. However, Qing policy changed with the establishment of Xinjiang province in 1884. In response to British and Russian military action in Xinjiang and Tibet, the Qing sent Army units which performed remarkably well against British units.
The abdication of the Qing emperor inevitably led to the controversy about the status of territories in Tibet and Mongolia. It was and remains the position of Mongols and Tibetan nationalists, that because they owed allegiance to the Qing monarch, that with the abdication of the Qing, they owed no allegiance to the new Chinese state. This position was rejected by the Republic of China and subsequent People's Republic of China which claims that these areas were integral parts of Chinese dynasties even before the Qing, and that regardless of Hans, Manchus, Mongols, or other ethnic groups, all established Sino-centric based dynasties, and claimed legitimacy and history as part of imperial China over two thousands years. The Western powers accepted the latter theory, partly in order to prevent a scramble for China.
Bureaucracy

Qing Dynasty vases, in the Calouste Gulbenkian Museum, Lisbon
The Qing Dynasty inherited many important institutions from the preceding Ming dynasty. The formal structure of the Qing government centered around the Emperor as the absolute ruler, who presided over six ministries (or boards), each headed by two presidents (
Ch: ''Shàngshū,'' 尚書;
Ma: ''Aliha amban'') and assisted by four vice presidents (Ch: ''Shìláng,'' 侍郎; Ma: ''Ashan i amban''). In contrast to the Ming system, however, Qing ethnic policy dictated that appointments were split between Manchu noblemen and Han officials who had passed the highest levels of the
state examinations. The Grand Secretariat (Ch: ''Nèigé'' 內閣; Ma: ''Dorgi yamun''), which had been an important policy making body during Ming, lost its importance during Qing and evolved into an imperial chancery. The institutions which had been inherited from the Ming dynasty formed the core of the Qing "outer court", which handled routine matters and was located in the southern part of the Forbidden City.
In order not to let the routine administration take over the running of the empire, the Manchu Qing emperors made sure that all important matters were decided in the "Inner Court," which was dominated by the imperial family and Manchu nobility and which was located in the northern part of the Forbidden City. A central part of the inner court was the '
Grand Council', a body initially in charge of military and intelligence matters, but which later assumed the role of supervising all government departments. Ministers posted to the Grand Council served as the emperor's
privy council and they were collectively known as privy councillors.
[9]
The six ministries and their respective areas of responsibilities were as follows:
'Board of Civil Appointments' (Ch: ''Lìbù,'' 吏部; Ma: ''Hafan i jurgan'') - The personnel administration of all civil officials - including evaluation, promotion, and dismissal. It was also in charge of the 'honours list'.
'Board of Finance ' (Ch: ''Hùbù'', 户部; Ma: ''Boigon i jurgan'') - The literal translation of the Chinese word 'hù'(户)is 'household'. For much of the Qing Dynasty's history, the government's main source of revenue came from taxation on landownership supplemented by official monopolies on essential household items such as salt and tea. Thus, in the predominantly agrarian Qing dynasty, the 'household' was the basis of imperial finance. The department was charged with revenue collection and the financial management of the government.
'Board of Rites' (Ch: ''Lǐbù,'' 禮部; Ma: ''Dorolon i jurgan'') - This was responsible for all matters concerning protocol at court, which included not just the periodic worshiping of ancestors and various gods by the Emperor—in his capacity as the "Son of Heaven" (Tiānzǐ, 天子), to ensure the smooth running of the empire—but also looking after the welfare of visiting ambassadors from tributary nations. The Chinese concept of courtesy (lǐ, 禮), as taught by Confucius, was considered an integral part of education. An intellect was said to "know of books and courtesy (rites)" ("知書達禮"). Thus, the ministry's other function was to oversee the nationwide civil examination system for entrance to the bureaucracy. Because democracy was unknown to pre-Republican China, neo-Confucian philosophy saw state sponsored exams as the way to legitimize a regime by allowing the intelligentsia participation in an otherwise autocratic and unelected system.

A stamp in Qing Dynasty
'Board of War' (Ch: ''Bīngbù,'' 兵部; Ma: ''Coohai jurgan'') - Unlike its
Ming Dynasty predecessor, which had full control over all military matters, the Qing Dynasty Board of War had very limited powers. First, the
Eight Banners were under the direct control of the Emperor and hereditary Manchu and Mongolian princes, leaving the ministry only with authority over the
Green Standard Armies. Furthermore, the ministry's functions were purely administrative - campaigns and troop movements were monitored and directed by the Emperor, first through the Manchu ruling council, and later through the Grand Council.
'Board of Punishments' (Ch: Xíngbù, 刑部; Ma: ''Beidere jurgan'') - The Board of Punishments handled all legal matters, including the supervision of various law courts and prisons. The
Qing legal framework was relatively weak compared to modern day legal systems, as there was no separation of executive and legislative branches of government. The legal system could be inconsistent, and, at times, arbitrary, because the emperor ruled by decree and had final say on all judicial outcomes. Emperors could (and did) overturn judgements of lower courts from time to time. Fairness of treatment was also an issue under the apartheid system practised by the Manchu government over the Han Chinese majority. To counter these inadequacies and keep the population in line, the Qing maintained a very harsh penal code towards the Han populace, but it was no more severe than previous Chinese dynasties.
'Board of Works' (Ch: ''Gōngbù,'' 工部; Ma: ''Weilere jurgan'') - The Board of Works handled all governmental building projects, including palaces, temples and the repairs of waterways and flood canals. It was also in charge of minting coinage.
In addition to the six boards, there was a '
Court of Colonial Affairs' unique to the Qing government. This institution was established to supervise the administration of Tibet and the Mongolian lands. As the empire expanded, it took over administrative responsibility of all minority ethnic groups living in and around the empire, including early contacts with Russia—then seen as a tribute nation. The office had the status of a full ministry and was headed by officials of equal rank. However, appointees were at first restricted only to candidates of Manchurian and Mongolian ethnicity.
Even though the Board of Rites and the Court of Colonial Affairs performed some duties of a foreign office, they fell short of developing into a professional foreign service. This stemmed from the traditional imperial world view of seeing China as the centre of the world and viewing all foreigners as uncivilized barbarians unworthy of equal diplomatic status. It was not until 1861—a year after losing the
Second Opium War to the Anglo-French coalition—that the Qing government bowed to foreign pressure and created a proper foreign affairs office known by as the '
Zongli Yamen'. The office was originally intended to be temporary and was staffed by officials seconded from the Grand Council. However, as dealings with foreigners became increasingly complicated and frequent, the office grew in size and importance, aided by revenue from customs duties which came under its direct jurisdiction.
Military
Beginnings and early development

The
Qianlong Emperor’s Southern Inspection Tour, Scroll Twelve: Return to the Palace (detail), 1764—1770, by Xu Yang
The development of Qing military system can be divided into two broad periods separated by the
Taiping rebellion (1850–1864). Early Qing military was rooted in the
Manchu banners first developed by
Nurhachi as a way to organize
Jurchen society beyond petty clan affiliations. There are eight banners in all, differentiated by colours. The banners in their order of precedence were as follows: Yellow, Bordered Yellow (i.e yellow banner with red border), White, Red, Bordered White, Bordered Red, Blue, & Bordered Blue. The Yellow, Bordered Yellow, and White banners were collectively known as the 'Upper Three Banners' (
Zh: 上三旗) and were under the direct command of the Emperor. Only Manchus belonging to the Upper Three Banners, and selected Han Chinese who had passed the highest level of martial exams were qualified to serve as the Emperor's personal bodyguards. The remaining Banners were known as 'The Lower Five Banners' (
Zh: 下五旗) and were commanded by hereditary Manchurian princes descended from
Nurhachi's immediate family, known informally as the 'Iron Cap Princes' (
Zh: 鐵帽子王). Together they formed the ruling council of the Manchu nation as well as high command of the army. In 1730, the
Emperor Yongzheng established the
Grand Council (
Zh: 軍機處;
Pinyin: Jūnjīchù;
Ma: ''Cooha nashūn i ba'') at first to direct day to day military operations, but gradually ''Junjichu'' took over other military and administrative duties and served to centralize authority unto the crown. However, the Iron Cap Princes continued to exercise considerable influence over the political and military affairs of Qing government well into the reign of the
Qianlong Emperor.
As Qing power expanded north of the
Great Wall in the last years of the
Ming Dynasty, the Banner system was expanded by
Nurhachi's son and successor
Hung Taiji to include mirrored
Mongolian and Han Banners. After capturing
Beijing in 1644 and as the
Manchu rapidly gained control of large tracts of former
Ming territory, the relatively small Banner armies were further augmented by the Green Standard Army (
Zh: 綠營兵) which eventually outnumbered Banner troops three to one. The Green Standard Army so-named after the colour of their battle standards was made up of those
Ming troops who had surrendered to the Qing. They maintained their
Ming era organization and were led by a mix of Banner and Green Standard officers. The Banners and Green Standard troops were standing armies, paid for by central government. In addition, regional governors from provincial down to village level maintained their own irregular local militias for police duties and disaster relief. These militias were usually granted small annual stipends from regional coffers for part-time service obligations. They received very limited military drill if at all and were not considered combat troops.
Peace and stagnation

A red
lacquer box from the Qing Dynasty.
Banner Armies were broadly divided along ethnic lines, namely Manchurian and Mongolian. Although it must be pointed out that the ethnic composition of Manchurian Banners was far from homogeneous as they include non-Manchu bondservants registered under the household of their Manchu masters. As the war with
Ming Dynasty progressed and the Han Chinese population under
Manchu rule increased,
Hung Taiji created a separate branch of Han Banners to draw on this new source of manpower. However these Han bannermen were never regarded by the government as equal to the other two branches due to their relatively late addition to the Manchu cause as well as their Han Chinese ancestry. The nature of their service - mainly as infantry, artillery and sappers, was also alien to the Manchurian nomadic traditions of fighting as cavalry. Furthermore, after the conquest the military roles played by Han Bannermen were quickly subsumed by the Green Standard Army. The Han Banners ceased to exist altogether after Emperor Yongzheng's Banner registration reforms aimed at cutting down imperial expenditures.
The socio-military origins of the
Banner system meant that population within each branch and their sub-divisions were hereditary and rigid. Only under special circumstances sanctioned by imperial edict were social movements between banners permitted. In contrast, the Green Standard Army was originally intended to be a professional force. However during protracted period of peace in China from the eighteenth to mid nineteenth century, recruits from farming communities dwindled, due partly to Neo-Confucianism's negative stance on military careers. In order to maintain strengths, the Green Standard Army began to internalize, and gradually became hereditary in practice.
After defeating the remnants of the
Ming forces, the
Manchu Banner Army of approximately 200,000 strong at the time was evenly divided; half was designated the Forbidden Eight Banner Army (禁旅八旗 ''Jìnlǚ Bāqí'') and was stationed in Beijing. It served both as the capital's garrison and Qing government's main strike force. The remainder of the Banner troops was distributed to guard key cities in China. These were known as the Territorial Eight Banner Army (駐防八旗 ''Zhùfáng Bāqí''). The
Manchu court keenly aware its own minority status reinforced a strict policy of racial segregation between the Manchus and Mongols from Han Chinese for fear of being sinitized by the latter. This policy applied directly to the Banner garrisons, most of which occupied a separate walled zone within the cities they were stationed in. In cities where there were limitation of space such as in Qingzhou (青州), a new fortified town would be purposely erected to house the Banner garrison and their families. Beijing being the imperial seat, the Regent Dorgon had the entire Chinese population forcibly relocated to the southern suburbs which became known as the "Outer Citadel" (外城 ''wàichéng''). The northern walled city called "Inner Citadel" (內城 ''nèichéng'') was portioned out to the remaining Manchu eight Banners, each responsibled for guarding a section of the Inner Citadel surrounding the
Forbidden City palace complex (紫禁城 ''Zǐjìnchéng'').
The policy of posting Banner troops as territorial garrison was not to protect but to inspire awe in the subjugated populace at the expense of their expertise as cavalry. As a result, after a century of peace and lack of field training the Manchurian Banner troops had deteriorated greatly in their combat worthiness. Secondly, before the conquest the Manchu banner was a 'citizen' army, and its members were Manchu farmers and herders obligated to provide military service to the state at times of war. The Qing government's decision to turn the banner troops into a professional force whose every welfare and need was met by state coffers brought wealth, and with it corruption, to the rank and file of the Manchu Banners and hastened its decline as a fighting force. This was mirrored by a similar decline in the Green Standard Army. During peace time, soldiering became merely a source of supplementary income. Soldiers and commanders alike neglected training in pursuit of their own economic gains. Corruption was rampant as regional unit commanders submitted pay and supply requisitions based on exaggerated head counts to the quartermaster department and pocketed the difference. When the
Taiping rebellion broke out in 1850s the Qing Court found out belatedly that the Banner and Green Standards troops could neither put down internal rebellions nor keep foreign invaders at bay.
Transition and modernization

General Zeng Guofan
Early during the
Taiping rebellion, Qing forces suffered a series of disastrous defeats culminating in the loss of the regional capital city of Nanjing (南京) in 1853. The rebels massacred the entire Manchu garrison and their families in the city and made it their capital. Shortly thereafter a
Taiping expeditionary force penetrated as far north as the suburbs of Tianjin (天津) in what was considered Imperial heartlands. In desperation the court ordered a Chinese mandarin
Zeng Guofan (曾國藩) to organize regional and village militias (Tuányǒng 團勇 and Xiāngyǒng 鄉勇) into a standing army to contain the rebellion. Zen's strategy was to rely on local gentries to raise a new type of military organization from those provinces that the Taiping rebels directly threatened. This new force became known as the
Xiang Army (湘軍), named after
Hunan region where it was raised. Xiang Army was a hybrid of local militia and a standing army. It was given professional training, but was paid for by regional coffers and funds its commanders—mostly Chinese gentries—could muster. Xiang Army and its successor the
Huai Army (淮軍) created by Zen's colleague and pupil
Li Hongzhang (李鴻章)were collectively called
Yongying (勇營).
Prior to forming and commanding the Xiang Army, Zen had no military experience. Being a classically educated Mandarin his blueprint for the
Xiang Army was taken from a historical source — the
Ming Dynasty General
Qi Jiguang (戚繼光) who because of the weakness of regular
Ming troops had decided to form his own 'private' army to repel raiding Japanese pirates in the mid sixteenth century. Qi's doctrine was based on Neo-Confucian ideas of binding troops' loyalty to their immediate superiors and also to regions from which they were raised. This initially gave the troops an excellent ''esprit de corps''. However, Qi's Army was an ad hoc solution to the specific problem of combating pirates, as was Zen's original intend for the
Xiang Army that to eradicate the Taiping rebels. However, circumstances saw that the Yongying system became a permanent institution within the Qing military, which in the long run created problems of its own for the beleaguered central government.

Qing troops training in Western drill
Firstly, Yongying system signalled the end of Manchu dominance in Qing military establishment. Although the Banners and Green Standard armies lingered on as parasites depleting resources, henceforth the Yongying corps became Qing government's de facto first-line troops. Secondly the Yongying corps were financed through provincial coffers and were led by regional commanders. This devolution of power weakened the central government's grip on the whole country, a weakness further aggravated by foreign powers vying to carve up autonomous colonial territories in different parts of the Empire in the later half of the nineteenth century. Despite these serious negative effects the measure was deemed necessary as tax revenue from provinces occupied and threatened by rebels had ceased to reach the cash-strapped central government. Finally, the nature of Yongying command structure fostered nepotism and cronyism amongst its commanders whom as they ascended up the bureaucratic ranks laid the seeds to Qing's eventual demise and the outbreak of regional
warlordism in China during the first half of the twentieth century.

Beiyang Army in training
By late nineteenth century, China was fast descending into a semi-colonial state. Even the most conservative elements within the Qing court could no longer ignore China's military weakness in contrast to the foreign "barbarians" literally beating down its gates. In 1860, during the
Second Opium War the capital Beijing was captured and the (Old) Summer Palace sacked by a relatively small Anglo-French coalition force numbering 25,000. Although the Chinese pride themselves as the inventor of gunpower, and firearms had been in continual use in Chinese warfare since as far back as the
Sung Dynasty, the advent of modern weaponry resulting from the European
Industrial Revolution had rendered China's traditionally trained and equipped army and navy obsolete. The government attempts to modernize during the
Self-Strengthening Movement were in the view of most historians with hindsight piecemeal and yielded little lasting results. Various reasons for the apparent failure of late-Qing modernization attempts have been advanced including the lack of funds, lack of political will, and unwillingness to depart from tradition. These reasons remain disputed.
[10]
Losing the
Sino-Japanese War of 1894–1895 was a watershed for the Qing government. Japan, a country long regarded by the Chinese as little more than an upstart nation of pirates, had convincingly beaten its larger neighbour and in the process annihilated the Qing government's pride and joy—it's modernized
Beiyang Fleet then deemed to be the strongest naval force in Asia. In doing so, Japan became the first Asian country to join the previously exclusively western ranks of colonial powers. The defeat was a rude awakening to the Qing court especially when set in the context that it occurred a mere three decades after the
Meiji reforms set a feudal Japan on course to emulate the Western nations in their economic and technological achievements. Finally, in December 1894, the Qing government took some concrete steps to reform military institutions and to re-train selected units in westernized drills, tactics and weaponry. These units were collectively called the
New Army (新式陸軍). The most successful of which was the
Beiyang Army (北洋軍) under the overall supervision and control of an ex-Huai Army commander, the Han Chinese general
Yuan Shikai (袁世凱), who exploited his position to eventually become Republic president, dictator and finally abortive emperor of China.
Fall of the dynasty
By the early twentieth century, mass civil disorder had begun and continuously grown. Empress Dowager Cixi and the Guangxu emperor both died in 1908, leaving a relatively powerless and unstable central authority.
Puyi, the eldest son of
Zaifeng, Prince Chun, was appointed successor at age two, leaving Zaifeng with the regency. This was followed by the dismissal of General
Yuan Shikai from his former positions of power. In mid 1911 Zaifeng created the "Imperial Family Cabinet", a ruling council of the Imperial Government almost entirely consisting of
Aisin Gioro relatives. This brought a wide range of negative opinions senior officials like
Zhang Zhidong.
The
Wuchang Uprising succeeded on
October 10,
1911, and was followed by a proclamation of a separate central government, the
Republic of China, in
Nanjing with
Sun Yat-sen as its provisional head. Numerous provinces began "separating" from Qing control. Seeing a desperate situation unfold, the Qing government brought an unwilling
Yuan Shikai back to military power, taking control of his
Beiyang Army, with the initial goal of crushing the revolutionaries. After taking the position of
Prime Minister (內閣總理大臣) and creating his own cabinet, Yuan went as far as to ask for the removal of Zaifeng from the regency. This removal later proceeded with directions from
Empress Dowager Longyu.
With Zaifeng gone, Yuan Shi-kai and his Beiyang commanders effectively dominated Qing politics. He reasoned that going to war would be unreasonable and costly, especially when noting that the Qing Government had a goal for constitutional monarchy. Similarly, Sun Yat-sen's government wanted a Republican constitutional reform, both aiming for the benefit of China's economy and populace. With permission from Empress Dowager Longyu, Yuan began negotiating with Sun Yat-sen, who decided that his goal had been achieved in forming a republic, and that therefore he could allow Yuan to step into the position of President of the Republic. In 1912, after rounds of negotiations, Longyu issued the
Imperial Edict bringing about the abdication of the child emperor
Puyi.
The collapse of the Qing dynasty in 1912 brought an end to over 2,000 years of imperial China and began an extended period of instability of warlord factionalism. Obvious political and economic backwardness combined with widespread criticism of Chinese culture led to questioning and doubt about the future. China's turbulent history since the overthrow of the Qing may be understood at least in part as an attempt to understand and recover significant aspects of historic Chinese culture and integrate them with influential new ideas that have emerged within the last century. The Qing dynasty is the source of much of this magnificent culture, but its perceived humiliations also provide much from which to learn.
Notes
1. Officially Qing court history states that Nurhachi died from illness. However because the cause of death mentioned is unusually vague, some historians propose that based on historical circumstantial evidence and through reading official Ming court history (Zh:《明熹宗实录》) Nurhaci might have died from cannon wounds sustained at the siege of Liaoning.
2. The exact figure of Li Zicheng's rebel forces at the battle of Shanhai Guan is disputed. Some primary sources such as the official Qing & Ming Court histories (Zh: 《清世祖实录》, 《明史》) cited 200,000. Whereas other sources cited figures varying from 60,000 to 400,000. In view of "established tradition" of victors inflating the strength of their vanquished enemies to play up the magnitude of their victories, as well as armies inflating their own strength to bolster morale, these "official figures" should be taken with a pinch of salt. Modern historians generally estimate Li's army to be no larger than 100,000.
3. The motivation of Wu Sangui's actions, apart from obvious self-preservation, was never fully explained. Most primary sources including the Ming and Qing official court histories are understandably bias against a person who turned "traitor" to both parties.
4. The classical Confucian tract 'On Filial Piety' states that "A person's body and hair, being gifts from one's parents, are not to be damaged." (Zh:《孝经》: 身体发肤,受之父母,不敢毁伤。), Prior to Qing dynasty adult Han Chinese men customarily did not cut their hair but instead wore it in the form of a top-knot.
5. Dorgon's death is sometimes misquoted as 1650 because the Chinese lunar calendar does not fall exactly into the corresponding solar year, the exact date of Dorgon's death was on the ninth day of the twelfth month in the seventh year of Shunzhi's reign (Zh: 順治七年十二月九日) which falls on January 1651.
6. This event was recorded by a visiting Italian Jesuit Martin Martinius in his account "Bellum Tartaricum" with original text in Latin, first published in Rome 1654. First English edition, London: John Crook, 1654.
7. Contrary to mainstream historical opinion, a 1912 manuscript copy of an earlier document titled "Chronicles of the Rebellion of Prince Yanping" (Zh:《延平王起义实录》) discovered in 1992 by a descendant of Koxinga claimed that Emperor Shuzhi was killed by a cannon barrage from Koxinga’s Navy while personally directing the campaign to capture the island of Taiwan.
8. For a translation of the emperor's letter, see Têng Ssu-yü and John King Fairbank, eds., ''China's Response to the West: A Documentary Survey, 1839–1923'' (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1979).
9. Beatrice S. Bartlett. ''Monarchs and Ministers: The Grand Council in Mid-Ch'ing China, 1723–1820. '' Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1991.
10. China in Disintegration, , Fredric, Wakeman, , ,
See also
★
Chinese sovereign
★
Dynasties in Chinese history
★
Emperor of China
★
Great Qing Legal Code
★
List of Emperors of the Qing Dynasty
★
List of Manchu clans
★
List of Recipients of Tribute from China
★
List of tributaries of Imperial China
★
Manchu official headwear
★
Mandate of Heaven
★
Manchu official Clothing
★
Military history of China
★
Republic of China
★
Table of Chinese monarchs
External links
★
Short History & Time-Line of the Qing Dynasty
★
Art of the early Qing dynasty
Recommended Reading
★ Elliot, Mark C. ''The Manchu Way: The Eight Banners and Ethnic Identity in Late Imperial China''. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2001
★ Spence, Jonathan. ''The Search for Modern China''. New York: W W Norton & Company, 1990
★ Spence, Jonathan. ''God's Chinese Son: The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom of Hong Xiuquan''. New York: W W Norton & Company, 1997