
Common depiction of the Men in Black.
The term 'Men in Black' ('MIB'), in
popular culture, is used in
UFO conspiracy theories to describe men dressed in black suits, sometimes with glowing eyes or other
monstrous features, claiming to be
government agents who attempt to harass or threaten
UFO witnesses into silence. "All MIB are not necessarily garbed in dark suits," writes American writer
Jerome Clark. "The term is a generic one, used to refer to any unusual, threatening or strangely behaved individual whose appearance on the scene can be linked in some fashion with a UFO sighting."
[1]
The phenomenon was initially and most frequently reported in the
1950s and
1960s; it is contemporaneous with many other
conspiracy theories. The MIB supposedly intimidated a reporter in Pinewood,
West Virginia to stop making articles in newspapers about the MIB's presence in Pinewood. Pinewood was near the area where alleged sightings of a creature dubbed the
Mothman were popular in the late 1960s, which make some people believe that the MIB are linked with the Mothman. According to
Google Maps, however,
Pinewood, West Virginia is not an actual place.
The term has also been adopted as a
tongue-in-cheek term in
geek culture for any generic suited government/corporate official. This usage has its roots in both the popularity of shows such as ''
The X-Files'' and
UFO culture among geeks, and the "threat" to
hackers of Men in Black actually coming for them (in the form of the
FBI or other
cybercrime institutions). As geek culture frequently finds itself in opposition to the "real world" of responsibility, the term is also something of a metaphor for the impending grip of adulthood.
Existence
The actual existence of Men in Black is the subject of much debate. Testimony of supposed witnesses is typically the only evidence presented in alleged Men in Black encounters and eyewitness testimony — however compelling it might seem — can be notoriously unreliable. (Indeed, one could argue that the involvement of Men in Black is often used as an excuse for lack of evidence in certain alleged UFO encounters, but it is unclear how often this has actually been the case).
Some versions of the Men in Black
conspiracy theory have led to the belief that the odd mannerisms and dress of the Men in Black are due to the fact that they are aliens or alien-human hybrids, and that their job is to eliminate physical evidence of alien involvement on earth. Others believe that they are actual government agents who intentionally dress and act ridiculously, in an attempt to get UFO witnesses to discredit themselves if they ever report such an encounter.
Physical description
Aside from the archetypal black suits and sunglasses, Men in Black are often described by alleged witnesses as wearing clothing either radically out of style or not ''yet'' in style. Their rarely-seen eyes are described as either slanted and vaguely Asian or "popping" as if from a
thyroid condition. They also are described as having very long fingers. Their voices are invariably described as "electronic," with no discernible accent. They also seem to drive antique black Cadillacs that seem and smell brand new.
[2]
Behavior
Men in Black always seem to have detailed information on the persons they contact, as if the individual had been under surveillance for a prolonged amount of time. They will also seemingly be confused by the nature of everyday items, such as pens, eating utensils or food, and use outdated slang. The behavior of Men in Black wildly varies from individual to individual, however. They will either act as if they are from an agency trying to collect data about the unexplained phenomena their subject has seen, ''or'' they seem to be trying to suppress information, trying to convince their subject the phenomena never existed. They will sometimes behave exceedingly furtive ''or'' be completely outgoing, with wide grins and disconcerting giggles.
[2]
Possible explanations
Psychological explanations
Men in Black accounts often feature "High Strangeness" or the "
Oz Factor" (the latter term coined by ufologist
Jenny Randles). Both terms are used to describe a strange sensation of "
otherness," or of a dreamlike
dissociation that accompanies some UFO reports. Such reports have led to speculation that Men in Black accounts are not part of any objective reality, but are best explained as altered states of consciousness, such as
fantasy-prone personalities,
sleep paralysis,
hypnagogic states, and the like.
In support of this hypothesis, Dash cites research by ufologist
Nigel Watson, which suggests that many Men in Black witnesses "are often undergoing some sort of mental upheaval at the time of their encounter." (Dash, 162) Furthermore, Dash also cites work by
folklorist Peter Rojcewicz "who himself encountered a possible MIB in his university library after entering what appears to have been an altered state of consciousness." (Dash, 416) See above for an account of Rojcewicz’s encounter.
Folkloric explanations
Although the phenomenon was initially and most frequently reported in the 1950s and 1960s, some researchers —
John Keel and others — have suggested similarities between Men in Black reports and earlier
demonic accounts. Rojcewicz noted that many Men in Black accounts parallel tales of people encountering
the devil: Neither Men in Black nor the devil are quite human, and witnesses often discover this fact midway through an encounter. The ''meaning'' of this parallel, however, has been the subject of debate.
Alien Explanations
Some UFO cases claim that these entities are aliens themselves. See the MAAR, other websites below and go to
www.ufocasebook.com/SEARCH: Men In Black.
Military/CIA explanations
More prosaically, Clark cites
Bill Moore, who asserts that "the Men in Black are really government people in disguise ... members of a rather bizarre unit of Air Force Intelligence known currently as the
Air Force Special Activities Center (
AFSAC) ... As of 1991, the AFSAC, headquartered in
Fort Belvoir, Virginia," and "under the operational authority of Air Force Intelligence Command centered at
Kelly Air Force Base in
Texas." (Clark, 321–22) Curiously, Moore also reports that AFSAC was inspired by the tales of Men in Black from the 1950s, and had nothing to do with those early accounts.
Similarly, Clark notes that Dr
Michael D. Swords has suggested, in an admittedly speculative manner, that the Barker/Bender Men in Black case (occurring shortly after the CIA-directed
Robertson Panel issued its recommendations to spy on civilian UFO groups) might have been a
psychological warfare experiment.
Individuals who may be considered a risk to national security based on loose conversation or publishing information after being 'read-in' to or 'read-out' of a special access program are sometimes visited by 'men in suits' according to an unnamed source at
AFFTC Det 3. These 'men' are very much human but can bring a tremendous amount of pressure to conform to the terms of the signed disclosure restriction statement due to the authority they have from an undisclosed federal agency.
Hoax explanation
In his article, "Gray Barker: My Friend, the Myth-Maker," John C. Sherwood reveals that at age eighteen, he collaborated with Gray Barker to create a hoax about what Barker called "blackmen," three mysterious UFO inhabitants who silenced Sherwood's pseudonymous identity, "Dr. Richard H. Pratt."
[4]
MIB references in popular culture
Film and television
There are many references to the Men in Black in film and television, some oblique and some straightforward. Notable examples include appearances in the 1997 film ''
Men in Black'' (and its 2002 sequel ''
Men in Black II''), the 1984 film ''
The Brother from Another Planet'', Not of this Earth, the ''
Matrix'' film trilogy and ''
The X-Files'' and ''
Dark Skies'' TV series. There are also many one-off references in other series, where the MIB stereotype is often used to portray a sinister figure of authority. This stereotype is played with in ''
Lilo and Stitch'', where the tall, intimidating Social Worker ''
Cobra Bubbles'' is a retired CIA agent who was involved in the Roswell incident. Also in the movie ''
The Forgotten'', a man, who doesn't dress in the black style is seen as one of these people performing an experiment. Agents of Sector Seven, a secret organization of the United States government, are also portrayed as MIB's in the 2007 movie
Transformers. In 2007, a short film called Truth, directed by Nic Collins, also centers around the Men in Black conspiracy, showing the Men in Black as aliens disguised as humans and using intimidation to discredit the witness. Also, features the
Majestic-12.
Music
British rock band
The Stranglers, by their own admission, became obsessed with the Men in Black theory around 1979–81, culminating in the release of their concept album ''
The Gospel According to the Meninblack''. They attributed the many calamities they suffered around the time to the influence of the Men in Black.
Pixies front man
Frank Black wrote about alien sightings and
Area 51 in his later work with the
Pixies, and continued with the topics into his solo career.
Books and comics
The Men in Black have been portrayed several times in comics, most notably in
Lowell Cunningham's 1990 Aircel comic ''
The Men in Black'', later adapted into the two films mentioned above. British comic
2000AD ran a series called "
Vector 13" about them.
Horror author
Kim Newman also wrote a short story, "Angel Down, Sussex," featuring MIB-like characters.
Author David Lynn Golemon wrote a novel, 'Event', featuring MIB characters.
''
Irregular Webcomic!'' also features a Man in Black as a recurring character in the Martians theme. A running gag is the fact that he appears immediately after anyone mentions aliens to convince them that aliens do not exist, sometimes even to the Martians themselves.
Italian comic
Martin Mystère features The Men in Black as a secret and ancient society of men aiming to hide knowledge and technology from humanity, waiting for the right moment in the future to unveil them.
Games
Role-playing and computer games also use the men in black, particularly, ''
Half Life'', ''
Half Life 2'', ''
Delta Green'', ''
Destroy All Humans!'', '', ''
Teenagers from Outer Space'', ''
Deus Ex'' and ''
Conspiracy X'', ''Heroes Unlimited: Aliens Unlimited".
See also
★
Anomalous phenomenon
★
Unidentified flying object
★
Aerial Phenomena Enquiry Network
★
Chilling effect
★
Forteana
★
Majestic 12
★
Phantom Social Workers
Notes
1. Clark, Jerome (1996). The UFO Encyclopedia, volume 3: High Strangeness, UFO’s from 1960 through 1979. Omnigraphis. 317-18.
2.
3.
4. Gray Barker: My Friend, the Myth-Maker
References
★
The UFO Encyclopedia, volume 3: High Strangeness, UFO’s from 1960 through 1979, , Jerome, Clark, Omnigraphis, , ISBN 1-55888-742-3
★
Albert Bender and the M.I.B. Mystery
★
They Knew Too Much about Flying Saucers, , Gray, Barker, University Books, , ISBN 1-881532-10-0
★
Final Report of the Scientific Study of Unidentified Flying Objects, , Edward, Condon, Batnam, , ISBN
★
Borderlands: The Ultimate Exploration of the Unknown, , Mike, Dash, Overlook, , ISBN 0-87951-724-7
★
Merionethshire Mysteries, , Beriah, Evans, The Occult Review,
★
Our Haunted Planet, , John, Keel, Fawcett, , ISBN
★
The Mothman Prophecies, , John, Keel, Saturday Review Press, , ISBN 0-7653-4197-2
★
The Complete Book of UFOs: An Investigation into Alien Contact and Encounters, , Jenny, Randles, Sterling, , ISBN 0-8069-8132-6
★
Heflin's 1965 Photos Validated, , Ann, Druffel, MUFON UFO Journal,
External links
★
★
Malevolent Alien Abduction Research Organization: Click on "Species", then See entry on "Men in Black"
★
www.maxpages.com/mapit/Men_In_Black
★
The Winter Hill MIB Case
★
Men In Black Are Aliens
★
Staging a UFO Crash to attract MIBs