Discover

(Redirected from Dartmouth College case)

'''Trustees of Dartmouth College v. Woodward''', 17 U.S. (4 Wheat.) 518 (1819), was an important United States Supreme Court case dealing with the application of the Contract Clause of the United States Constitution to private corporations.

Contents

Background

Case

Decision

See also

Background

The landmark case ''Dartmouth v. William H. Woodward'' is not without precedent. Earlier in the first instance of the Court invalidating a state legislative act the Supreme Court had ruled in ''Fletcher v. Peck'', , that contracts no matter how they were procured (in the case of ''Fletcher'', a land contract had been illegally obtained), cannot be invalidated by state legislation. Thus, the court, though working in an early era, was treading on familiar ground when it handed down ''Dartmouth.''

Case

In 1815, over thirty years after the conclusion of the American Revolution, the legislature of New Hampshire attempted to invalidate or alter Dartmouth's charter in order to reinstate the College's deposed president, effectively converting the school from a private to a public institution. The trustees of the College objected and sought to have the actions of the legislature declared unconstitutional.

The trustees retained Dartmouth alumnus Daniel Webster, a New Hampshire native who would later become a U.S. Senator from Massachusetts and Secretary of State under President Millard Fillmore. Webster argued the college's case against William H. Woodward, the state-approved secretary of the new board of trustees. Webster's speech in support of Dartmouth (which he described as "a small college," adding, "and yet there are those who love it") was so moving that it reportedly brought tears to Webster's eyes and apparently helped convince Chief Justice Marshall.

Decision

The decision, handed down on February 2, 1819, ruled in favor of the College and invalidated the act of the New Hampshire legislature, which in turn allowed Dartmouth to exist as a private institution and take back its buildings, seal, and charter. The majority opinion was, predictably, written by Marshall. The opinion reaffirmed Marshall's belief in the sanctity of a contract (also seen in ''Fletcher v. Peck'').
''Dartmouth'' was not a popular decision at the time, and a public outcry ensued. Thomas Jefferson's earlier commiseration with New Hampshire Governor Plumer stated essentially that the earth belongs to the living. Popular opinion influenced some state courts and legislatures to declare that state governments had an absolute right to amend or repeal a corporate charter. Today, however, ''Dartmouth'' is viewed positively as one of the most important Supreme Court rulings, strengthening the Contract Clause and limiting the power of the States to interfere with private charters, including those of commercial enterprises.

See also

★ List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 17

★ Dartmouth College

★ John Marshall

★ Contract Clause